Retained earnings are the profits a company holds back for reinvestment, instead of distributing them as dividends to shareholders. This portion of profit accumulates over time, reflecting a company’s ability to save and reinvest its earnings.
The value of retained earnings is significant for a business because they act as an internal source of funding. Rather than borrowing money or issuing new shares, businesses can use these retained profits to fund new projects, strengthen their balance sheet, or pay off debts. Moreover, strong retained earnings can help instil investor confidence by showing the company’s potential for growth without relying on external financing.
In their book titled “Buffettology: The Previously Unexplained Techniques That Have Made Warren Buffett the World’s Most Famous Investor”, Mary Buffett and David Clark have deliberated upon the question – “Does the Business get to retain its earnings?”
We will look into this concept of Retained Earnings in a much deeper manner in this blogpost.
Let us understand ‘Retained Earnings’ in a bit more detail:
As we’ve discussed, retained earnings are the part of a company’s profits that are kept within the business instead of being paid out as dividends to shareholders. This money is often reinvested into the company to fund growth, pay off debt, or enhance operations. To calculate retained earnings, you add the net profit (or subtract the net loss) from the previous period’s earnings and then subtract any dividends paid out to shareholders.
Retained Earnings = Previous Retained Earnings + Net Profit – Dividends Paid
Companies hold onto retained earnings to reinvest in their growth, which can boost shareholder value over time. These earnings are often used for expanding operations, reducing debt, funding research and development, or making capital investments.
Does the Business Get to Retain its Earnings?
We often hear that “Common Stocks” grow as companies earn more than they distribute as dividends. Retained earnings play a crucial role in measuring a company’s growth and stability. By holding onto some of its profits instead of paying them all out as dividends, a business can create a financial cushion that enables reinvestment. This reinvestment is key to driving sustainable growth.
While many businesses rely on retained earnings to replace plant and machinery, not all companies follow this pattern. Some businesses, especially those that don’t need constant equipment upgrades, can use their retained earnings to acquire new businesses or expand existing ones.
Warren Buffett, as discussed in Mary and David’s book, is a strong advocate for businesses that retain their earnings rather than paying out high dividends. He believes that dividends should only be paid when a company has no better use for its profits. Buffett points out that many of his investments, including Berkshire Hathaway, retain most of their earnings because they can reinvest them at high rates of return. However, if a company cannot reinvest its earnings effectively, returning the profits to shareholders through dividends or share repurchases is a smarter choice.
There’s also a significant concern about double taxation on dividends. First, the company pays tax on its total earnings, and then a portion of the after-tax profits is distributed as dividends to shareholders. These dividends are then taxed again when received by shareholders, leading to double taxation.
Experts, including Buffett, argue that it’s challenging for shareholders to invest this residual dividend money in ways that will outperform the company’s returns and offset the tax burden. In summary, while retaining earnings can fuel growth, paying dividends may only make sense when reinvesting isn’t a viable option, especially considering the complexities of taxation.
Reinvestment of Retained Earnings:
Retained earnings, shown on the balance sheet under shareholders’ equity, serve as a financial reserve for a company’s future needs. Reinvesting these earnings refers to the process where a company uses its retained profits to fuel activities that can drive growth, boost operational efficiency, or strengthen its financial foundation.
Companies often reinvest retained earnings in several key areas, such as launching new products, exploring new markets, expanding operations into new regions or countries, upgrading outdated equipment and technology, or developing and enhancing existing products. Additionally, these funds can be used to reduce existing debt, lowering interest costs, or even acquiring other businesses that align with the company’s goals and create synergies.
Warren Buffett is a big advocate of reinvesting retained earnings when it has the potential to generate high returns and increase shareholder value. He has famously said that the true test of a company’s ability to reinvest retained earnings is whether it can create at least one dollar of market value for every dollar of retained earnings. If a company fails to meet this threshold, it may need to reconsider its strategy for using retained earnings.
Here’s a quick look at the Advantages and Disadvantages of Retained Earnings to help you understand this important aspect of this financial strategy of retaining earnings by a company:
Advantages:
- Retained Earnings fuels growth by using profits to expand without borrowing.
- Keeps finances flexible—no need to take on debt or sell more shares.
- Boosts value of the company over time, benefiting shareholders as the company grows.
- Funds your business without having to rely on external sources.
- Saves on taxes since reinvested earnings aren’t taxed like dividends.
Disadvantages:
- Missed opportunities if shareholders could have earned more elsewhere (though the chances of this may be rare).
- Excess cash can pile up due to the retained earnings, and become a missed chance for more impactful investments.
- Some shareholders may be unhappy if they prefer regular dividends instead of reinvested profits (as there are a bunch of investors who invest to get regular dividend income).
- Risk of poor decisions if reinvestment projects don’t pay off.
Conclusion:
Retained earnings serve as a crucial measure of a company’s financial health. A steady increase in retained earnings indicates a profitable and expanding business. When companies wisely retain and reinvest their earnings, they can boost their value, often resulting in higher stock prices and increased wealth for shareholders in the long run.
However, the success of reinvesting these earnings hinges on the company’s ability to identify opportunities that offer high returns and align with its long-term strategic objectives.
Whether you’re an investor or a business owner, understanding the power of retained earnings and their reinvestment can provide a solid foundation for sustainable growth and financial health in the years to come.
Check out my other article on how to find out an investable business.
Connect with me on LinkedIn for regular insights on investments, personal finance, money management, and more!
